The Pragmatics of Suicide - Instablogs
The Pragmatics of Suicide
Matt P , Torreon: Jul 27 2008
Made Popular Jul 27 2008
South Korea :

Korea Beat has translated a new story discussing the disturbing rise in the suicide rate in Korea. It reminded me of a few months ago when Japan underwent a suicide wave of sorts. For a few weeks there were a scattering of news stories about Japanese suicide. The new way was a concoction with liquid detergent or something. Mixed properly the method emits a poisonous gas that kills those close to it and can be dangerous for those near.

This way of suicide caught my attention because it was more than just suicide, it was a trend. The new hip way to end your life. All the cool kids were doing it.

I’m reminded of an eerily relevant passage from Malcolm Gladwell’s book “The Tipping Point,” where he discusses the boom in suicides
in Micronesia. He says,

“Virtually all suicides on the islands, in fact, are identical variations on [basic format]…In all but a few cases, the victim observes the same procedure, as if there were a strict, unwritten protocol about the correct way to take one’s own life.”

The suicides in Japan reminded me of this because they were more than just one taking ones own life. By bowing to this trend the person committing suicide was making a statement, they are no longer themselves, but rather a social idea.

Gladwell goes on to write that

“Immediately after stories about suicides appeared, suicides in the area served by the newspaper jumped. In the case of national stories, the rate jumped nationally. (Marilyn Monroes death was followed by a temporary 12 percent increase in the national suicide rate.”

It seems coincidental then, that after the initial story about Japanese Detergent suicide (which was prominent because investigators had to clear out an entire apartment complex for safety reasons) a week or so later 3 others committed suicide in the same way in a suicide pact.

What does this have to do with Korea?

Along with Japan, Korea has one of the highest suicide rates in the world. Additionally, the suicide rate in Korea is climbing at a much faster rate than Japan. It’s almost like they want to catch up.

If you look at Korean society it’s not hard to guess why the rate is becoming so high. From the time a Korean student is old enough to go to school they began a lifetime of rigorous study. It’s not just public education, but private tutors. Korea seems to be caught up in one big case of “Keeping up with the Joneses.” If one family sends their child to three private lessons a day their neighbor must match it, or go higher. If they don’t their child might get left behind.

One might say, then, that it is the burden of constant work that gets to people, but I would argue it’s not the case. Korea also has one of the highest rates of unemployment among college graduates in the world. It’s the consequence of a society where education is seen as the key to salvation. Everybody is educated and smart, but there are still only a certain amount of high quality jobs to go around.

Suicide then isn’t the result of too much work. It’s the result of working your entire life for the singular goal of succeeding in the economic world and then realizing you still might not get a good job because there are millions of others out there just as qualified, if not more qualified, than you. Hard work doesn’t cause suicide as much as not living up to familial, societal and personal expectations.

In his book “A Whole New Mind” Daniel Pink discusses how societies that are advancing are facing a dilemma of adapting its goals and purpose. Once a certain economic freedom is reached by a society it will inevitably change its goals to achieve more spiritual ends.
The principal is simple; those struggling to eat don’t spend their days contemplating existence. Those who are provided for, do.
Korea is an interesting example because it has developed so rapidly. The parents of the current generation lived with a singular goal: to raise Korea from one of the poorest countries in the world to its 11th strongest economy. Mission accomplished my friends.

What are the goals of this next generation then? Are they supposed to beat the fastest GDP growth rate over a 30 year period that the world has ever seen?

Korea is what America would be if it jumped from the Revolutionary
War to 2008 in the span of 50 years. That’s a lot of history they’ve missed out on. Granted, they’ve had thousands of years of culture to fall back on, but the change is so rapid that it is fast losing it’s stranglehold on Korean culture. They are replacing their cultural safety net with an economic one. Is it that surprising then that the nation is still very much trying to find itself?

Is it that surprising that in a culture that stresses education as the key to success that when failure does happen people act out with extreme measures?

History is a force that is happening at this very instant. The social trends that occur today are products of the past and indications of the future. Korea will change, and if recent history is any indication it will change very rapidly. I see it already, in the younger generations; they look at me differently than the older ones. They will talk to me on the street, approach me and say hello. Korea will get through this and history will go on to a new stage of growth. It’s just sad to see so many people get caught between the generational stages with no place to go and only a bottle of laundry detergent to fall back on.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Fariha Jamil
Lahore, Pakistan
Its is indeed shocking and scary at the same time! What would draw so many people to kill themselves...

Science and technology has provided physical comforts to man but not mental and spiritual. The world is thirsty for guidence... its tragic how these societies are so blind to the spiritual needs of human beings! Having no knowledge of the spirit and purpose of creation is destroying the lives of these people...
2 Stars
The ”disenchantment of the world ”, Weber, has never been present as it seems today.
2 Stars
Jaiyant Cavale
Bangalore, India
Suicide sometimes but not always reflects the state of a community or a society. Suicide that results from mental illness is different.. But that which results due to social maladies such as the ones you have described is something that is very disturbing.. And mental illness is caused by psycho-social factors too.. So at the end of the day a society can either nurture or crush a person’s life...
1 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
Suicide may be a trend in some places but it remains a very small minority. The numbers cannot compare with murder or homicide.

The more alarming phenomenon is self-mutilation, which by the looks of it is really NOT wanting to kill oneself.
1 Stars
Great read.

What boggles my mind is why Japan and Korea don’t seem to be taking their own hint, when their suicide rates are placed on a global scale.
2 Stars
Can we really trust in the statistics about suicide? I can imagine only a few countries (Japan included) where is possible to trust in these informations.

I don’t know, but suicide may be more usual than we think. To measure something so complex as suicide, it’s necessary to have reliable information. Suicide is a taboo and as far as I know, people hide this kind of information. Many accidental deaths may not be accidental at all.

Sleeping pills, for instance. Take 2, or 10, hardly will kill you. But 50 or more will. Are we so naive to believe that someone that die because of these pills really took for accident?
2 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
They are recorded as mortality statistics, and since it isn’t really a crime, it doesn’t become police matter.
1 Stars
It should be, but the thing is not that simple. Self-destruction is very normal in humans. One self-destructive person when gets him or herself in a car accident not for accident. Suicidal behavior doesn’t manifest itself in a standardized way.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Sorry, I typed something wrong above. People who suffer from some psychological disorders can kill themselves appearing like an accident.
Car accidents is an example: human mind play tricks, like distracting us in very bad moments.
Add your Comment